• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Where premium quality meets exceptional value. ZEISS Conquest HDX.

Today at the feeder (8 Viewers)

Not today at the feeder but two days ago, we got invaded by Song Sparrows. We normally have couple foraging under the feeders but suddenly there were a least a dozen. There could have been more because they were flying back and forth to and from cover. Migrating or a bunch of newly fledged birds?
 
I love these suet feeders. Discourages the Grackles & Jays but allows for the woodies and smaller birds to have at it. This is quite normal for the inside cage to be occupied while the Woodpeckers are feeding from the bottom.
 

Attachments

  • DSC_0022a.jpg
    DSC_0022a.jpg
    319.1 KB · Views: 43
I haven't seen that particular pattern of feeder. Can Hairy's get at the suet?
As an aside, what's the plural of Hairy in the context of the woodpecker? Hairys or Hairies?:-C
 
We are inundated with Mourning Doves. They are on the gravel of the driveway, on the phone wires, under the feeders. There are also several Northern Flickers hanging around, that's very normal for this time of year but I've never seen this many doves in the fall.
 
I just came in from filling the sunflower seed feeder. I used up the last of my seed. I had hoped that it would last until we head south 1 Nov. but not so. I guess I'll have to buy some more.
There are feathers on the ground near the feeder so I must have had a visit from a Sharpie. I've heard commotion out there a few times but when I checked I didn't see anything going on.
 
First time in I can't remember how long I came home to all the feeders still full and then I saw the feathers on the ground. Guess Hawk activity was busy yesterday.
 
Winter Wren turned up on the feeder, right at sunset. Took a walnut piece, then started poking around in the Poke berry patch, maybe for spiders. Earliest Winter Wren in the yard, ever. Dark-eyed Juncos, and Whited-throated sparrows just showing up the sunday past, and late by about 3 weeks compared to previous years.
 
Sorry when it sounds harsh for native English speakers, no offense intended.

stonechat, you said in an earlier post you are coming to Cape May.
Not a reason in the world why you couldn't come over early and lend a hand.

While your at it, why the heck did the Winter Wren take a piece
walnut, drop it, and then jump to the ground and starting chasing what it eats naturally?
 
Last edited:
Feeding during the warm time of the year and putting down feeders and leaving when it start´s to be cold I consider selfish.

Sorry when it sounds harsh for native English speakers, no offense intended.
It doesn't only sound harsh, it sounds very rude and offense is taken. I have looked carefully at the ethics of stopping feeding and am quite comfortable with what I do. Cornell University has done studies that show that it does no harm to stop feeding birds as they get the bulk of the food from natural sources even when feeders are available.
 
stonechat, you said in an earlier post you are coming to Cape May.
Not a reason in the world why you couldn't come over early and lend a hand.

While your at it, why the heck did the Winter Wren take a piece
walnut, drop it, and then jump to the ground and starting chasing what it eats naturally?
Wow! A Winter Wren. You are very fortunate, I've never had one at my feeders.
 
On the face of it, it does sound cruel to provide a regular food source and then withdraw it at the coldest time of year.

On the other hand, that source has given birds the opportunity to build fat reserves for the coming months.
 
You might find the following interesting. It is from the National Audubon Society. I investigated the implications of stopping feeding as carefully as I could, including contacting the Ornithology Lab at Cornell, before I made any decisions.

>When should I start and stop feeding birds?
Seed-eating birds get their food from a variety of sources throughout a day, so what people provide is a convenient and easy source of food, but not necessary to help the species of birds that come to feeders. So, starting or stopping your feeding at any particular time of year won't have much of an impact on those birds. The only exception is if there is a bad snow or ice storm and natural food is buried for a period of time. In that event, the seed you put out could be life-saving for some birds. Some people choose to only feed in winter, but others feed year-round to attract them closer to enjoy them up close.

Nectar-eating birds, such as hummingbirds and orioles, begin their migration north from the tropics in January. Hummingbirds may arrive in southern states as early as January, the middle states in March or April, and upper Great Lake states in May. As hummingbirds head south again, the birds farther north will stop at feeders along their way south; so some people leave their feeders out for a few weeks after they notice their summer birds have left, in the event passers-by stop to refuel.

For people who only feed during the summer, they can stop feeding in the fall whenever they want. Migratory birds leave on their own schedule, regardless of food availability, so continued feeding will not prevent birds from migrating as they should.

For more information, visit our Bird Feeding Basics page.<
 
stonechat, you said in an earlier post you are coming to Cape May.
Not a reason in the world why you couldn't come over early and lend a hand.
AFAIK, I never mentioned that I´ll visit Cape May. But when one need help when banding birds in the Pt. Pelee area I don´t hesitate to offer a few days.

While your at it, why the heck did the Winter Wren take a piece walnut, drop it, and then jump to the ground and starting chasing what it eats naturally?
|:S|
 
It doesn't only sound harsh, it sounds very rude and offense is taken.
Well, if that´s your understanding ....

[...] Cornell University has done studies that show that it does no harm to stop feeding birds as they get the bulk of the food from natural sources even when feeders are available.
Correct, that´s why many people are questioning the feeding of birds during the warm periods of the year.
But, I read in the last two days here on BF that there is allready snow and cold weather in Canada. And I doubt that it´s adviced to put the feeders down then.
Though I understand that you can´t feed when you´re moving to southern countries.
 
Canada is a very big country. Here today the sun is shining and the grass is green. The forecast for Friday is 15 C. There probably won't be significant snow here until after Christmas.
 
Thank you! Believe me when I say that I don't do it without a lot of thought but I believe that feeding during the breeding and rearing season is important.
 
Warning! This thread is more than 9 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top