Aha, I didn't know we were in one of those movies from a trial where the lawyer twists his questions in order to get the witness on the box to confess he or she did murder the victim
Following your simplistic approach:
Yes I looove Porro prism binoculars, I use them on a daily basis and love what they can offer.
No, I don't think that a Porro is better than a roof, because, as I said, the view is made up of many aspects, and the prisms used are just one part of the equation.
If I could daydream my perfect binocular yes it would be a Porro prism binocular. It would be a 7x32 Swarovski PL (a new series they come up with in my dreams, taking the NL into Porro territory), with 9º FOV, the grip and feel of an EL, a weight of 450-480 g (around a pound) and the size of a Leupold Yosemite/Kowa YF, with the eyecups of the 8x32 EL and the contrast of the 7x35 Retrovid. There you go