RSPB HDX binoculars - equivalents/alternatives? Plus chromatic aberration
On Sunday I headed over to RSPB Pulborough for their "Binocular and Telescope open weekend". My current binoculars were a Christmas present aged 14 and they aren't much good for anything. Now that I know I want to birdwatch (and deer watch) it was time for a better pair.
I should say that I worked as a photographer a decade ago so I know what good glass looks like. I'm also that person who spots when white UPVC is slightly dirty when no one else does. You can guess where this is going...
The volunteers there were extremely helpful and started me off with their new "Harrier" binoculars. The first choice was 8x32 or 8x42? To me, despite the extra weight, 8x42 seemed preferable. It was brighter and I like the wider field of view; ideal (I think) when trying to spot deer at dawn or dusk.
The Harrier's image quality disappointed. And the chromatic aberration (CA)... oh my. Turns out I am particularly sensitive to it, and it is a REAL turn-off for me.
Next I tried the RSPB BG.PC binoculars at £380. They were considerably better. Looking through them felt more like stepping into the picture (vs the Harrier which was like viewing an oversharpened TV).
One volunteer recommended I tried the HDX, his go-to binoculars. Apart from colour (the BG.PC more magenta, the HDX greener) I didn't notice much difference, until it came to watching the raptors. Up against the clouds, the HDX (mostly) controlled the CA. The BG.PC was better than the cheaper ones but still had a wide band of magenta above and green below the birds.
I liked the HDX. It had the best CA control I saw that day, wider field of view (7.8 degrees), noticeably lighter than the BG.PC (I appreciate that), good microcontrast and a seemingly flatter image(?). It felt good in the hand. Variations in colour may have been easier to see than the BG.PC, but I'd have to look again to be sure.
But... at £680 was near twice what I'd planned to spend. Without other brands to compare with I had no way to tell whether the RSPB range was overpriced, or the HDX a complete bargain compared to the Zeiss and Leica binoculars the reserve also sold (at £1300+).
I have no problem spending that much for something that'll last a lifetime, but if the same quality is available for less (and the ergonomics work) I'd rather do that.
So... can forum members recommend any binoculars I should consider, and any places to do so? I've seen In Focus do field sales events but can't make the next two in this area.
PS: At Pulborough I also saw my first pair of red kites. Worth going for that alone! :t:
On Sunday I headed over to RSPB Pulborough for their "Binocular and Telescope open weekend". My current binoculars were a Christmas present aged 14 and they aren't much good for anything. Now that I know I want to birdwatch (and deer watch) it was time for a better pair.
I should say that I worked as a photographer a decade ago so I know what good glass looks like. I'm also that person who spots when white UPVC is slightly dirty when no one else does. You can guess where this is going...
The volunteers there were extremely helpful and started me off with their new "Harrier" binoculars. The first choice was 8x32 or 8x42? To me, despite the extra weight, 8x42 seemed preferable. It was brighter and I like the wider field of view; ideal (I think) when trying to spot deer at dawn or dusk.
The Harrier's image quality disappointed. And the chromatic aberration (CA)... oh my. Turns out I am particularly sensitive to it, and it is a REAL turn-off for me.
Next I tried the RSPB BG.PC binoculars at £380. They were considerably better. Looking through them felt more like stepping into the picture (vs the Harrier which was like viewing an oversharpened TV).
One volunteer recommended I tried the HDX, his go-to binoculars. Apart from colour (the BG.PC more magenta, the HDX greener) I didn't notice much difference, until it came to watching the raptors. Up against the clouds, the HDX (mostly) controlled the CA. The BG.PC was better than the cheaper ones but still had a wide band of magenta above and green below the birds.
I liked the HDX. It had the best CA control I saw that day, wider field of view (7.8 degrees), noticeably lighter than the BG.PC (I appreciate that), good microcontrast and a seemingly flatter image(?). It felt good in the hand. Variations in colour may have been easier to see than the BG.PC, but I'd have to look again to be sure.
But... at £680 was near twice what I'd planned to spend. Without other brands to compare with I had no way to tell whether the RSPB range was overpriced, or the HDX a complete bargain compared to the Zeiss and Leica binoculars the reserve also sold (at £1300+).
I have no problem spending that much for something that'll last a lifetime, but if the same quality is available for less (and the ergonomics work) I'd rather do that.
So... can forum members recommend any binoculars I should consider, and any places to do so? I've seen In Focus do field sales events but can't make the next two in this area.
PS: At Pulborough I also saw my first pair of red kites. Worth going for that alone! :t:
Last edited: